$5+ million reasons for a MB-based beef plant

Alberta cattle producers get more for their animals than Manitoba producers. But how much more?

MCEC along with the management team behind the proposed new Winnipeg-based beef plant crunched the numbers and discovered that Manitoba producers are losing out on more than $5 million a year compared to their Alberta counterparts. The reason is simple: Alberta is home to federally-inspected beef plants and Manitoba is not.

The analysis shows the price differential over the first 10 months of 2011 between Alberta and Manitoba on fed steers was $10.16/100lbs. On an average fed steer of 1,300 lbs, that works out to $130 per animal.

We also know that the minimum differential on other cattle for transportation alone is $50/head.

The proposed new Winnipeg plant is expected to take 62,500 head/year.

  • 40 % to be fed cattle: 25,000 x $130 = $3.25 million
  • 60 % to be non-fed: 37,500 x $50 = 1.88 million
  • Total: $5.13 million
Manitoba has approximately 8,700 beef producers, which works out to an annual drain of $590 per producer.
What’s wrong with this picture?
The price differential is based on transportation, handling and other costs associated with getting cattle from here to Alberta. Most industry watchers predict transportation costs will only rise alongside input costs such as feed. That means the price differential will only get worse.
By investing in a local plant, MCEC is trying to level that playing field and give Manitoba producers a better chance at long term profitability and sustainability.
MCEC wants to thank Manitoba producers for their ongoing support of this important initiative.